It's a close call for me between Obama and Hillary, and I'm still not sure about how I will vote in November, but for now I am pulling for Obama to win tomorrow in Iowa. The most recent Des Moines Register poll shows Obama leading with 32% of support from likely Democratic caucusgoers compared to Hillary's 25%. However, Hillary still leads Obama in national polls by more than 21 points - a gap that may close quickly should Obama win in Iowa.
Obama and Hillary have similar economic goals (including tax cuts for middle-class Americans and tweaking of international trade laws). On the environment, both Obama and Hillary have aggressive plans to address global warming and energy independence (fyi, the NYT editorial provided a concise accounting of the candidates' environmental plans yesterday).
Obviously, this election will probably be won or lost on the Iraq issue. And when it comes to Iraq, I find Hillary's plan to be a little bit more realistic and organized than Obama's. Obama says he will get all of the troops out of Iraq in 16 months -- a doubtful scenario -- and he seems to think that simply talking to Middle East leaders will start a successful diplomatic alternative to our current troop "surge." Hillary also plans to bring the troops home as quickly as possible, but shrewdly refuses to set a timetable for such action. Hillary's diplomatic mission seems a bit more structured and organized than Obama's right now.
For these reasons, on the issues alone, I probably favor Hillary. Why, then, have I continued to support Obama? Well, for one, it's because of speeches like this (on reconciling faith and politics). I'm just impressed with Obama's vision of the future -- it really is hopeful, and refuses to accept the cynical realism of modern United States politics. I do realize that being President is about more than just speech-making, but then again, as Obama says, if one voice can change a room, then one voice can change a nation (it somehow doesn't sound cheesy when he says it).
Perhaps I just fit the billing as another hopeful young person naively inspired by Obama's rhetoric. That could be true. But in a race as close as this one, speech-making may be the difference maker.
I think Sen. Obama's biggest problem is his heritage, not Iraq. Bigotry against Muslim or those with Muslim names is high. This bigotry is played out by the news media who keep mentioning the senator by his full name with an emphasis on his middle name.
How stupid! But America is playing right into their hands. The ridiculous thing is there are few U.S. presidents who don't share names with infamous men in history. However, no one would have said anything like "You can't trust William Jefferson Clinton because he has the same name as William Bonin (the Freeway Killer).
Posted by: Heidi W. | Wednesday, January 02, 2008 at 06:31 PM